Back to stories

Why do so many Category visions fail to stick?

20th August, 2018

By Natalie Little

Category Leadership Aisle d3867277feb154defec9b24a5714fadb

What do Category Management, the World Wide Web and Taylor Swift have in common?

They all turned 30 recently.

That’s right: Category Management is a bona fide veteran of the CPG world. So surely most businesses know exactly which category drivers are the most important to their own growth strategy, right?


We regularly hear clients telling us ‘Our category vision hasn’t gained traction’, ‘Category? That’s range and merchandising, right?’ or ‘I just don’t quite understand what ‘category’ actually is…’.

So what’s going on?

A Category Evolution

To be fair, you can’t say Category hasn’t done its best to stay ahead of the game during its 3 decades.

The eight-step Category Management approach that was born back in 1989 was crucial in bringing a category and shopper mindset into CPG companies across the globe. Roll into the noughties and the availability of shopper data led to a Category Development approach, with suppliers and retailers working together to develop joint category growth initiatives.

With an increasingly complex retail and shopper landscape, more advanced suppliers are now adopting a Category Leadership mindset. This brings together shopper and customer insight throughout the planning process to create plans that deliver a 4-way win for the retailer, the shopper (or patient), the consumer – and themselves.

But the failure of many of these companies to drive brand growth alongside category growth, or to deliver a tangible change at the point of purchase has led many to question the value of category resource. Google ‘death of category management’ and you’ll get plenty of hits.

The problem with Category Visions

Too often, Category Visions become over-complex, intellectualised exercises. They don’t survive beyond the function that created them, and they’re nowhere near being the sales and marketing 'adhesive' they were intended to be. We see examples of category strategies being at odds to commercial strategies, with no formal alignment into internal processes, creating unnecessary internal tension.

The value impact of category drivers ends with the ‘big number in the launch presentation’, and is rarely tracked. Selling stories are still retrospectively forced to ‘find’ a category angle. The traditional and much coveted role of Category Captain has been abandoned by many retailers, fearing getting ‘too close’ to one supplier, and preferring to gain multiple views from a number of different suppliers. Well, wouldn’t you?

Category that’s fit for the future, now

The fact is, the world has changed – and continues to change rapidly. Shoppers are savvier than ever before. Channels are more complex than ever before. We have access to more data than ever before. And yet fundamentally, needs are the same as they were back in 1989.

Suppliers want to grow, retailers want to grow, and shoppers want to find the right product solution, easily accessible when they need it – they’re just a bit more vocal about it than they used to be.

At OxfordSM we believe that Category is as relevant and crucial as it was 30 years ago – but it must evolve to be 'fit for the future'.

Our approach to Category Growth Strategy is based on 4 key principles:

If you are looking to get your category vision to stick, please get in touch, we'd love to hear from you.

Join our mailing list